Acts and Omissions
November 11, 2007 by VM
As a normal rule, an act is not an omission and the law differentiates between the two. As with most rules, there is an exception which takes place today. Omitting to speak for two minutes at 11 o’clock is an act of remembrance and solidarity. One need not approve of particular wars to understand that it is not an army’s job to argue about whether or not to fight. When a soldier goes to fight, he or she does so on behalf of us all, whether we want them to or not. The risk thus taken is one we should honour.
The loss of one, individual, life reverberates through families, personal relationships and communities. The loss of millions of lives has, arguably, an exponential effect. It does not seem too much to ask us all to think, for 120 seconds of one day of a year, of countless lives ended, countless lives altered and countless lives unlived, and to wear a paper flower to show that one has done it.
The prophet Malachi says, “For from the rising of the sun to its setting, My Name is great amongst the nations” (1:11), to which we have added “we will remember“. Dear Diary, whether one believes in God or not, today would seem to be an appropriate day to reflect that when we ask others to pay with their lives, it ought at least to be for something we value. Simply saying “what a waste” comes close to nihilism: if we believe that to be so (and some may and some may not), then we must, surely, ask ourselves what we would do instead. Whilst we are doing that, we may perhaps profitably honour those who no longer have that capacity.
[...] I believe we should honour those who died so we may live the lives we lead in modern Britain. Victorian Maiden, of Ruthie’s Law, makes the point better than I am able [...]
I was moved by recent interviews with some of the remaining few World War One survivors, and by the strength of feeling they had about a war that happended such a long time ago albeit within their living memories. One survivor, Harry Patch when interviewed asked “Why did they die?” Another when asked what we should learn from the war responded “that there should be no more wars”
So why is it that we like killing each other so much? Does our desire for territory and resources override our basic nature to preserve life?
Evolution is not that evolved?